On The Borderline

Understanding Borderline Normal forms in Sperm Morphology

Sperm morphology is an important predictor of male fertility and is often the parameter used to determine fertility treatment. Ironically, sperm morphology is often the most difficult part of a semen profile to interpret due to poor standardization of morphologic variant classification, coupled with high subjectivity and variability in performance of the analysis.

Our Competency/Proficiency Challenges reveal several serious problems in morphology analysis:

    Many labs do not know what classification system is used in their labs.
    Technologists often use the wrong reference atlas for the classification system they are reporting.
    Many laboratories are confused by the difference between the two major systems currently used for the diagnosis of infertility: WHO laboratory manual 3rd Edition (1992) and Strict/WHO laboratory manual 4th/5thEdition.

Traditional vs. Strict

The primary difference between these two classification systems is in how borderline normal sperm are classified. WHO 3rd Edition classifies borderline sperm as normal, while the Strict system classifies them as abnormal. To easily compare systems, examine at least 200 sperm with a 100X oil objective and classify them as normal, borderline or abnormal according to the criteria below. Only intact recognizable sperm should be counted in the differential. Do NOT count tailless heads or headless tails.

Borderline Normal Forms
Round head shape with a normal acrosome.
V-Shape – straight sides to a point at the base
Curly Bracket – a pinched projection or tip at the neck
Irregular – roughness, waviness, or indentation in the contour of the head shape

In all cases, the variation does not dramatically change the shape of the head from oval.



% Normal = (# Normal + # Borderline)/# Sperm analyzed * 100


% Normal = # Normal / # Sperm analyzed * 100

return to Academy

11811 Shaker Blvd, Suite 330      Cleveland OH 44120       USA       216-491-0030 Phone         216-491-0032 Fax         Staff Bios
copyright © Fertility Solutions Inc.